Jewish Futures

Home » Bar & Bat Mitzvah » Re-imagine Bar Mitzvah to be More Like Camp, Not at Camp by Rabbi Isaac Saposnik

Re-imagine Bar Mitzvah to be More Like Camp, Not at Camp by Rabbi Isaac Saposnik

Every so often, parents ask me if their child’s bar (or bat) mitzvah can take place at camp over the summer. Camp, they tell me, is the place where their child feels most connected to being Jewish. I always tell these parents how touched and honored I am that they would ask … and then I send them back to their congregation, because, at my core, I believe that bar mitzvah should take place within the embrace of family and community.

But here’s the challenge: for many of our kids, camp is their Jewish community. We are the place where they pull themselves up to the table of Judaism, explore their place in the world, and begin to build a deeper connection with the larger Jewish world. And we are the place where they really grow into young adults. Unfortunately, for too many of our kids this doesn’t happen as easily in synagogues; bar mitzvah, which many of our families see as the “capstone” of the religious school experience, is the test for which our kids have been cramming for years and years. And, just like most tests they take in middle school, they will forget much of it the next day. Why? Because while we expect them to stand on the bimah to “become an adult” by singing in a language they don’t understand, worrying about their voice cracking, and smiling nervously at their grandparents’ friends, many of them – appropriately for their age – are still being kids and thinking about who they will dance with at the party later that night. We are trying to get our kids to find meaning by doing things that we, as adults, find meaningful. And while this is a lovely idea, we all too often forget this most simple fact: they aren’t adults.

If we want bar mitzvah to be meaningful for our kids, we have to find ways for it to speak to them as kids (not only to us as adults): it must grow out of experiential learning, be based in a community of their peers, have age appropriate connections that are designed to be long-lasting, and maybe, just maybe, be fun. Imagine if these things (all of which exist in summer camp) were integral parts of the bar mitzvah experience, so kids could have a powerful experience similar to those they have at camp surrounded not only by their friends but also by their family and home community.

The goal of bar mitzvah is to turn kids into committed Jewish adults. Clearly, it’s not working as well as we’d like. On the other hand, camp does work; research shows that kids who go to Jewish summer camp have a stronger and deeper connection to the Jewish community than their non-camp-going peers. Knowing this, how can we re-imagine bar mitzvah to make sure it is – like camp – a transformative experience? How can we make sure our kids see bar mitzvah as just the beginning of a lifelong commitment to the Jewish community? And how can we use this ritual to welcome them into Jewish adulthood in a way that makes them want to be here?

 Rabbi Isaac Saposnik

Rabbi Isaac Saposnik is Executive Director of Camp JRF.

Advertisements

4 Comments

  1. “it must grow out of experiential learning, be based in a community of their peers, have age appropriate connections that are designed to be long-lasting, and maybe, just maybe, be fun”

    Reb Isaac – thank you for contributing to this conversation and I agree with your approach and I think that you are asking the right questions. I hope that you don’t mind me suggesting an additional element to your list above. AND IT MUST BE CHALLENGING. Adolescents are motivated by challenges: academic, physical, social, political — and as much as we need to add fun to b’nai mitzvah, we also need to be mindful of how the challenge of b’nai mitzvah is connected to the challenge of becoming an adult. I’ve seen this happen in numerous ways – connected to public speaking, to social action projects, to Hebrew language learning, to writing, to changing roles within the family. When students are given appropriate challenges, they get the message that Judaism asks something of them.

    • Isaac Saposnik says:

      I agree that when teens are challenged, they feel a greater sense of accomplishment and excitement about the task at hand. But I think we walk a fine line. Being thirteen comes with so many challenges of its own (zits, cracking voice, middle school); wouldn’t it be great if bar mitzvah could be a comfortable, welcoming, “warm and fuzzy” experience that our teens don’t get in so many other places? Certainly Judaism should challenge our teens, but it shouldn’t be a challenge FOR them.

  2. Cindy Shulak-Rome says:

    “The goal of bar mitzvah is to turn kids into Jewish adults.” I think this is a statement we need to rethink. That may have been the goal when the ritual was initially established in Judaism, but I think we all acknowledge that in today’s society a 13 year old is not even close to being an adult. So, what does it mean to become bar/bat mitzvah at age 13 in today’s culture? If we really want to re-imagine the bar/bat mitzvah I think we either need to re-examine our goal, or perhaps re-examine the timing, or both!

    • Isaac Saposnik says:

      Yes! Bar mitzvah at 13 makes sense if you’re getting married at 15 and having children at 18. But in today’s world, many 13-year-olds aren’t even expected to make their beds, let alone function in any “adult” way. If we moved bar mitzvah to 18 — to coincide with the ability to vote, serve in the military, leave home, and go to college — we could connect our religious lifecycle with our secular lifecycle. This would be more in keeping with the idea of making Jewish adults and would, certainly, allow us to think at a higher level about what bar mitzvah could entail.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: